Simon Willison’s Weblog

The 3 AI Use Cases: Gods, Interns, and Cogs. Drew Breunig introduces an interesting new framework for categorizing use cases of modern AI:

• Gods refers to the autonomous, human replacement applications - I see that as AGI stuff that's still effectively science fiction.
• Interns are supervised copilots. This is how I get most of the value out of LLMs at the moment, delegating tasks to them that I can then review, such as AI-assisted programming.
• Cogs are the smaller, more reliable components that you can build pipelines and automations on top of without needing to review everything they do - think Whisper for transcriptions or maybe some limited LLM subtasks such as structured data extraction.

Drew also considers Toys as a subcategory of Interns: things like image generators, “defined by their usage by non-experts. Toys have a high tolerance for errors because they’re not being relied on for much beyond entertainment.”

# 20th October 2024, 10:12 pm / drew-breunig, ai-assisted-programming, generative-ai, ai, llms

New in NotebookLM: Customizing your Audio Overviews. The most requested feature for Google's NotebookLM "audio overviews" (aka automatically generated podcast conversations) has been the ability to provide direction to those artificial podcast hosts - setting their expertise level or asking them to focus on specific topics.

Today's update adds exactly that:

Now you can provide instructions before you generate a "Deep Dive" Audio Overview. For example, you can focus on specific topics or adjust the expertise level to suit your audience. Think of it like slipping the AI hosts a quick note right before they go on the air, which will change how they cover your material.

I pasted in a link to my post about video scraping and prompted it like this:

You are both pelicans who work as data journalist at a pelican news service. Discuss this from the perspective of pelican data journalists, being sure to inject as many pelican related anecdotes as possible

Here's the resulting 7m40s MP3, and the transcript.

It starts off strong!

You ever find yourself wading through mountains of data trying to pluck out the juicy bits? It's like hunting for a single shrimp in a whole kelp forest, am I right?

Then later:

Think of those facial recognition systems they have for humans. We could have something similar for our finned friends. Although, gotta say, the ethical implications of that kind of tech are a whole other kettle of fish. We pelicans gotta use these tools responsibly and be transparent about it.

And when brainstorming some potential use-cases:

Imagine a pelican citizen journalist being able to analyze footage of a local council meeting, you know, really hold those pelicans in power accountable, or a pelican historian using video scraping to analyze old film reels, uncovering lost details about our pelican ancestors.

Plus this delightful conclusion:

The future of data journalism is looking brighter than a school of silversides reflecting the morning sun. Until next time, keep those wings spread, those eyes sharp, and those minds open. There's a whole ocean of data out there just waiting to be explored.

And yes, people on Reddit have got them to swear.

# 17th October 2024, 5:27 pm / notebooklm, data-journalism, google, llms, ai, generative-ai, gemini

Gemini API Additional Terms of Service. I've been trying to figure out what Google's policy is on using data submitted to their Google Gemini LLM for further training. It turns out it's clearly spelled out in their terms of service, but it differs for the paid v.s. free tiers.

The paid APIs do not train on your inputs:

When you're using Paid Services, Google doesn't use your prompts (including associated system instructions, cached content, and files such as images, videos, or documents) or responses to improve our products [...] This data may be stored transiently or cached in any country in which Google or its agents maintain facilities.

The Gemini API free tier does:

The terms in this section apply solely to your use of Unpaid Services. [...] Google uses this data, consistent with our Privacy Policy, to provide, improve, and develop Google products and services and machine learning technologies, including Google’s enterprise features, products, and services. To help with quality and improve our products, human reviewers may read, annotate, and process your API input and output.

But watch out! It looks like the AI Studio tool, since it's offered for free (even if you have a paid account setup) is treated as "free" for the purposes of these terms. There's also an interesting note about the EU:

The terms in this "Paid Services" section apply solely to your use of paid Services ("Paid Services"), as opposed to any Services that are offered free of charge like direct interactions with Google AI Studio or unpaid quota in Gemini API ("Unpaid Services"). [...] If you're in the European Economic Area, Switzerland, or the United Kingdom, the terms applicable to Paid Services apply to all Services including AI Studio even though it's offered free of charge.

Confusingly, the following paragraph about data used to fine-tune your own custom models appears in that same "Data Use for Unpaid Services" section:

Google only uses content that you import or upload to our model tuning feature for that express purpose. Tuning content may be retained in connection with your tuned models for purposes of re-tuning when supported models change. When you delete a tuned model, the related tuning content is also deleted.

It turns out their tuning service is "free of charge" on both pay-as-you-go and free plans according to the Gemini pricing page, though you still pay for input/output tokens at inference time (on the paid tier - it looks like the free tier remains free even for those fine-tuned models).

# 17th October 2024, 3:06 am / gemini, llms, google, generative-ai, training-data, ai, fine-tuning

Un Ministral, des Ministraux (via) Two new models from Mistral: Ministral 3B and Ministral 8B - joining Mixtral, Pixtral, Codestral and Mathstral as weird naming variants on the Mistral theme.

These models set a new frontier in knowledge, commonsense, reasoning, function-calling, and efficiency in the sub-10B category, and can be used or tuned to a variety of uses, from orchestrating agentic workflows to creating specialist task workers. Both models support up to 128k context length (currently 32k on vLLM) and Ministral 8B has a special interleaved sliding-window attention pattern for faster and memory-efficient inference.

Mistral's own benchmarks look impressive, but it's hard to get excited about small on-device models with a non-commercial Mistral Research License (for the 8B) and a contact-us-for-pricing Mistral Commercial License (for the 8B and 3B), given the existence of the extremely high quality Llama 3.1 and 3.2 series of models.

These new models are also available through Mistral's la Plateforme API, priced at $0.1/million tokens (input and output) for the 8B and $0.04/million tokens for the 3B.

The latest release of my llm-mistral plugin for LLM adds aliases for the new models. Previously you could access them like this:

llm mistral refresh # To fetch new models
llm -m mistral/ministral-3b-latest "a poem about pelicans at the park"
llm -m mistral/ministral-8b-latest "a poem about a pelican in french"

With the latest plugin version you can do this:

llm install -U llm-mistral
llm -m ministral-8b "a poem about a pelican in french"

# 16th October 2024, 3:40 pm / mistral, llms, ai, generative-ai, llm

My Jina Reader tool. I wanted to feed the Cloudflare Durable Objects SQLite documentation into Claude, but I was on my iPhone so copying and pasting was inconvenient. Jina offer a Reader API which can turn any URL into LLM-friendly Markdown and it turns out it supports CORS, so I got Claude to build me this tool (second iteration, third iteration, final source code).

Paste in a URL to get the Jina Markdown version, along with an all important "Copy to clipboard" button.

# 14th October 2024, 4:47 pm / projects, markdown, ai-assisted-programming, jina, claude-3-5-sonnet, claude, generative-ai, ai, llms

An LLM TDD loop (via) Super neat demo by David Winterbottom, who wrapped my LLM and files-to-prompt tools in a short Bash script that can be fed a file full of Python unit tests and an empty implementation file and will then iterate on that file in a loop until the tests pass.

# 13th October 2024, 7:37 pm / llm, ai-assisted-programming, python, generative-ai, pytest, ai, llms

lm.rs: run inference on Language Models locally on the CPU with Rust (via) Impressive new LLM inference implementation in Rust by Samuel Vitorino. I tried it just now on an M2 Mac with 64GB of RAM and got very snappy performance for this Q8 Llama 3.2 1B, with Activity Monitor reporting 980% CPU usage over 13 threads.

Here's how I compiled the library and ran the model:

cd /tmp
git clone https://github.com/samuel-vitorino/lm.rs
cd lm.rs
RUSTFLAGS="-C target-cpu=native" cargo build --release --bin chat
curl -LO 'https://huggingface.co/samuel-vitorino/Llama-3.2-1B-Instruct-Q8_0-LMRS/resolve/main/tokenizer.bin?download=true'
curl -LO 'https://huggingface.co/samuel-vitorino/Llama-3.2-1B-Instruct-Q8_0-LMRS/resolve/main/llama3.2-1b-it-q80.lmrs?download=true'
./target/release/chat --model llama3.2-1b-it-q80.lmrs --show-metrics

That --show-metrics option added this at the end of a response:

Speed: 26.41 tok/s

It looks like the performance is helped by two key dependencies: wide, which provides data types optimized for SIMD operations and rayon for running parallel iterators across multiple cores (used for matrix multiplication).

(I used LLM and files-to-prompt to help figure this out.)

# 11th October 2024, 7:33 pm / llm, rust, ai-assisted-programming, generative-ai, ai, llms

openai/openai-realtime-console. I got this OpenAI demo repository working today - it's an extremely easy way to get started playing around with the new Realtime voice API they announced at DevDay last week:

cd /tmp
git clone https://github.com/openai/openai-realtime-console
cd openai-realtime-console
npm i
npm start

That starts a localhost:3000 server running the demo React application. It asks for an API key, you paste one in and you can start talking to the web page.

The demo handles voice input, voice output and basic tool support - it has a tool that can show you the weather anywhere in the world, including panning a map to that location. I tried adding a show_map() tool so I could pan to a location just by saying "Show me a map of the capital of Morocco" - all it took was editing the src/pages/ConsolePage.tsx file and hitting save, then refreshing the page in my browser to pick up the new function.

Be warned, it can be quite expensive to play around with. I was testing the application intermittently for only about 15 minutes and racked up $3.87 in API charges.

# 9th October 2024, 12:38 am / nodejs, javascript, openai, websockets, generative-ai, ai, llms, react

Anthropic: Message Batches (beta) (via) Anthropic now have a batch mode, allowing you to send prompts to Claude in batches which will be processed within 24 hours (though probably much faster than that) and come at a 50% price discount.

This matches the batch models offered by OpenAI and by Google Gemini, both of which also provide a 50% discount.

Update 15th October 2024: Alex Albert confirms that Anthropic batching and prompt caching can be combined:

Don't know if folks have realized yet that you can get close to a 95% discount on Claude 3.5 Sonnet tokens when you combine prompt caching with the new Batches API

# 8th October 2024, 6:18 pm / gemini, anthropic, claude, generative-ai, openai, ai, llms, alex-albert

SVG to JPG/PNG. The latest in my ongoing series of interactive HTML and JavaScript tools written almost entirely by LLMs. This one lets you paste in (or open-from-file, or drag-onto-page) some SVG and then use that to render a JPEG or PNG image of your desired width.

I built this using Claude 3.5 Sonnet, initially as an Artifact and later in a code editor since some of the features (loading an example image and downloading the result) cannot run in the sandboxed iframe Artifact environment.

Here's the full transcript of the Claude conversation I used to build the tool, plus a few commits I later made by hand to further customize it.

The code itself is mostly quite simple. The most interesting part is how it renders the SVG to an image, which (simplified) looks like this:

// First extract the viewbox to get width/height
const svgElement = new DOMParser().parseFromString(
    svgInput, 'image/svg+xml'
).documentElement;
let viewBox = svgElement.getAttribute('viewBox');
[, , width, height] = viewBox.split(' ').map(Number);

// Figure out the width/height of the output image
const newWidth = parseInt(widthInput.value) || 800;
const aspectRatio = width / height;
const newHeight = Math.round(newWidth / aspectRatio);

// Create off-screen canvas
const canvas = document.createElement('canvas');
canvas.width = newWidth;
canvas.height = newHeight;

// Draw SVG on canvas
const svgBlob = new Blob([svgInput], {type: 'image/svg+xml;charset=utf-8'});
const svgUrl = URL.createObjectURL(svgBlob);
const img = new Image();
const ctx = canvas.getContext('2d');
img.onload = function() {
    ctx.drawImage(img, 0, 0, newWidth, newHeight);
    URL.revokeObjectURL(svgUrl);
    // Convert that to a JPEG
    const imageDataUrl = canvas.toDataURL("image/jpeg");
    const convertedImg = document.createElement('img');
    convertedImg.src = imageDataUrl;
    imageContainer.appendChild(convertedImg);
};
img.src = svgUrl;

Here's the MDN explanation of that revokeObjectURL() method, which I hadn't seen before.

Call this method when you've finished using an object URL to let the browser know not to keep the reference to the file any longer.

# 6th October 2024, 7:57 pm / claude-3-5-sonnet, images, claude, ai, llms, svg, claude-artifacts, javascript, ai-assisted-programming, generative-ai

marimo v0.9.0 with mo.ui.chat. The latest release of the Marimo Python reactive notebook project includes a neat new feature: you can now easily embed a custom chat interface directly inside of your notebook.

Marimo co-founder Myles Scolnick posted this intriguing demo on Twitter, demonstrating a chat interface to my LLM library “in only 3 lines of code”:

import marimo as mo
import llm

model = llm.get_model()
conversation = model.conversation()
mo.ui.chat(lambda messages: conversation.prompt(messages[-1].content))

I tried that out today - here’s the result:

marimo.ui.chat() takes a function which is passed a list of Marimo chat messages (representing the current state of that widget) and returns a string - or other type of renderable object - to add as the next message in the chat. This makes it trivial to hook in any custom chat mechanism you like.

Marimo also ship their own built-in chat handlers for OpenAI, Anthropic and Google Gemini which you can use like this:

mo.ui.chat(
    mo.ai.llm.anthropic(
        "claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620",
        system_message="You are a helpful assistant.",
        api_key="sk-ant-...",
    ),
    show_configuration_controls=True
)

# 5th October 2024, 10:59 pm / llm, marimo, python, llms, ai, generative-ai

Gemini 1.5 Flash-8B is now production ready (via) Gemini 1.5 Flash-8B is "a smaller and faster variant of 1.5 Flash" - and is now released to production, at half the price of the 1.5 Flash model.

It's really, really cheap:

• $0.0375 per 1 million input tokens on prompts <128K
• $0.15 per 1 million output tokens on prompts <128K
• $0.01 per 1 million input tokens on cached prompts <128K

Prices are doubled for prompts longer than 128K.

I believe images are still charged at a flat rate of 258 tokens, which I think means a single non-cached image with Flash should cost 0.00097 cents - a number so tiny I'm doubting if I got the calculation right.

OpenAI's cheapest model remains GPT-4o mini, at $0.15/1M input - though that drops to half of that for reused prompt prefixes thanks to their new prompt caching feature (or by half if you use batches, though those can’t be combined with OpenAI prompt caching. Gemini also offer half-off for batched requests).

Anthropic's cheapest model is still Claude 3 Haiku at $0.25/M, though that drops to $0.03/M for cached tokens (if you configure them correctly).

I've released llm-gemini 0.2 with support for the new model:

llm install -U llm-gemini
llm keys set gemini
# Paste API key here
llm -m gemini-1.5-flash-8b-latest "say hi"

# 3rd October 2024, 8:16 pm / vision-llms, gemini, anthropic, openai, ai, llms, google, generative-ai, llm, llm-pricing

Announcing FLUX1.1 [pro] and the BFL API (via) FLUX is the image generation model family from Black Forest Labs, a startup founded by members of the team that previously created Stable Diffusion.

Released today, FLUX1.1 [pro] continues the general trend of AI models getting both better and more efficient:

FLUX1.1 [pro] provides six times faster generation than its predecessor FLUX.1 [pro] while also improving image quality, prompt adherence, and diversity.

Black Forest Labs appear to have settled on a potentially workable business model: their smallest, fastest model FLUX.1 [schnell] is Apache 2 licensed. The next step up is FLUX.1 [dev] which is open weights for non-commercial use only. The [pro] models are closed weights, made available exclusively through their API or partnerships with other API providers.

I tried the new 1.1 model out using black-forest-labs/flux-1.1-pro on Replicate just now. Here's my prompt:

Photograph of a Faberge egg representing the California coast. It should be decorated with ornate pelicans and sea lions and a humpback whale.

The FLUX models have a reputation for being really good at following complex prompts. In this case I wanted the sea lions to appear in the egg design rather than looking at the egg from the beach, but I imagine I could get better results if I continued to iterate on my prompt.

The FLUX models are also better at applying text than any other image models I've tried myself.

# 3rd October 2024, 7:14 pm / stable-diffusion, ai, generative-ai, replicate, text-to-image

Building an automatically updating live blog in Django. Here's an extended write-up of how I implemented the live blog feature I used for my coverage of OpenAI DevDay yesterday. I built the first version using Claude while waiting for the keynote to start, then upgraded it during the lunch break with the help of GPT-4o to add sort options and incremental fetching of new updates.

# 2nd October 2024, 3:42 pm / claude, ai, django, llms, javascript, ai-assisted-programming, generative-ai, chatgpt

llama-3.2-webgpu (via) Llama 3.2 1B is a really interesting models, given its 128,000 token input and its tiny size (barely more than a GB).

This page loads a 1.24GB q4f16 ONNX build of the Llama-3.2-1B-Instruct model and runs it with a React-powered chat interface directly in the browser, using Transformers.js and WebGPU. Source code for the demo is here.

It worked for me just now in Chrome; in Firefox and Safari I got a “WebGPU is not supported by this browser” error message.

# 30th September 2024, 4:27 pm / webassembly, webgpu, generative-ai, llama, ai, transformers-js, llms

mlx-vlm (via) The MLX ecosystem of libraries for running machine learning models on Apple Silicon continues to expand. Prince Canuma is actively developing this library for running vision models such as Qwen-2 VL and Pixtral and LLaVA using Python running on a Mac.

I used uv to run it against this image with this shell one-liner:

uv run --with mlx-vlm \
  python -m mlx_vlm.generate \
  --model Qwen/Qwen2-VL-2B-Instruct \
  --max-tokens 1000 \
  --temp 0.0 \
  --image https://static.simonwillison.net/static/2024/django-roadmap.png \
  --prompt "Describe image in detail, include all text"

The --image option works equally well with a URL or a path to a local file on disk.

This first downloaded 4.1GB to my ~/.cache/huggingface/hub/models--Qwen--Qwen2-VL-2B-Instruct folder and then output this result, which starts:

The image is a horizontal timeline chart that represents the release dates of various software versions. The timeline is divided into years from 2023 to 2029, with each year represented by a vertical line. The chart includes a legend at the bottom, which distinguishes between different types of software versions. [...]

# 29th September 2024, 9:38 pm / vision-llms, apple, python, generative-ai, uv, ai, llms, mlx, qwen