Simon Willison’s Weblog

mlx-vlm (via) The MLX ecosystem of libraries for running machine learning models on Apple Silicon continues to expand. Prince Canuma is actively developing this library for running vision models such as Qwen-2 VL and Pixtral and LLaVA using Python running on a Mac.

I used uv to run it against this image with this shell one-liner:

uv run --with mlx-vlm \
  python -m mlx_vlm.generate \
  --model Qwen/Qwen2-VL-2B-Instruct \
  --max-tokens 1000 \
  --temp 0.0 \
  --image https://static.simonwillison.net/static/2024/django-roadmap.png \
  --prompt "Describe image in detail, include all text"

The --image option works equally well with a URL or a path to a local file on disk.

This first downloaded 4.1GB to my ~/.cache/huggingface/hub/models--Qwen--Qwen2-VL-2B-Instruct folder and then output this result, which starts:

The image is a horizontal timeline chart that represents the release dates of various software versions. The timeline is divided into years from 2023 to 2029, with each year represented by a vertical line. The chart includes a legend at the bottom, which distinguishes between different types of software versions. [...]

# 9:38 pm / vision-llms, apple, python, generative-ai, uv, ai, llms, mlx, qwen

Ensuring a block is overridden in a Django template (via) Neat Django trick by Tom Carrick: implement a Django template tag that raises a custom exception, then you can use this pattern in your templates:

{% block title %}{% ensure_overridden %}{% endblock %}

To ensure you don't accidentally extend a base template but forget to fill out a critical block.

# 7:25 pm / django, python

OpenFreeMap (via) New free map tile hosting service from Zsolt Ero:

OpenFreeMap lets you display custom maps on your website and apps for free. […] Using our public instance is completely free: there are no limits on the number of map views or requests. There’s no registration, no user database, no API keys, and no cookies. We aim to cover the running costs of our public instance through donations.

The site serves static vector tiles that work with MapLibre GL. It deliberately doesn’t offer any other services such as search or routing.

From the project README looks like it’s hosted on two Hetzner machines. I don’t think the public server is behind a CDN.

Part of the trick to serving the tiles efficiently is the way it takes advantage of Btrfs:

Production-quality hosting of 300 million tiny files is hard. The average file size is just 450 byte. Dozens of tile servers have been written to tackle this problem, but they all have their limitations.

The original idea of this project is to avoid using tile servers altogether. Instead, the tiles are directly served from Btrfs partition images + hard links using an optimised nginx config.

The self-hosting guide describes the scripts that are provided for downloading their pre-built tiles (needing a fresh Ubuntu server with 300GB of SSD and 4GB of RAM) or building the tiles yourself using Planetiler (needs 500GB of disk and 64GB of RAM).

Getting started is delightfully straightforward:

const map = new maplibregl.Map({
  style: 'https://tiles.openfreemap.org/styles/liberty',
  center: [13.388, 52.517],
  zoom: 9.5,
  container: 'map',
})

I got Claude to help build this demo showing a thousand random markers dotted around San Francisco. The 3D tiles even include building shapes!

Zsolt built OpenFreeMap based on his experience running MapHub over the last 9 years. Here’s a 2018 interview about that project.

It’s pretty incredible that the OpenStreetMap and open geospatial stack has evolved to the point now where it’s economically feasible for an individual to offer a service like this. I hope this turns out to be sustainable. Hetzner charge just €1 per TB for bandwidth (S3 can cost $90/TB) which should help a lot.

# 9:41 pm / maps, ai-assisted-programming, geospatial, openstreetmap

DjangoTV (via) Brand new site by Jeff Triplett gathering together videos from Django conferences around the world. Here's Jeff's blog post introducing the project.

# 4:48 am / jeff-triplett, django

Some Go web dev notes. Julia Evans on writing small, self-contained web applications in Go:

In general everything about it feels like it makes projects easy to work on for 5 days, abandon for 2 years, and then get back into writing code without a lot of problems.

Go 1.22 introduced HTTP routing in February of this year, making it even more practical to build a web application using just the Go standard library.

# 11:43 pm / web-development, go, julia-evans, http

Niche Museums: The Vincent and Ethel Simonetti Historic Tuba Collection. DjangoCon was in Durham, North Carolina this year and thanks to Atlas Obscura I found out about the fabulous Vincent and Ethel Simonetti Historic Tuba Collection. We got together a group of five for a visit and had a wonderful time being shown around the collection by curator Vincent Simonetti. This is my first update to Niche Museums in quite a while, it's nice to get that project rolling again.

# 10:23 pm / museums, music

django-plugin-datasette. I did some more work on my DJP plugin mechanism for Django at the DjangoCon US sprints today. I added a new plugin hook, asgi_wrapper(), released in DJP 0.3 and inspired by the similar hook in Datasette.

The hook only works for Django apps that are served using ASGI. It allows plugins to add their own wrapping ASGI middleware around the Django app itself, which means they can do things like attach entirely separate ASGI-compatible applications outside of the regular Django request/response cycle.

Datasette is one of those ASGI-compatible applications!

django-plugin-datasette uses that new hook to configure a new URL, /-/datasette/, which serves a full Datasette instance that scans through Django’s settings.DATABASES dictionary and serves an explore interface on top of any SQLite databases it finds there.

It doesn’t support authentication yet, so this will expose your entire database contents - probably best used as a local debugging tool only.

I did borrow some code from the datasette-mask-columns plugin to ensure that the password column in the auth_user column is reliably redacted. That column contains a heavily salted hashed password so exposing it isn’t necessarily a disaster, but I like to default to keeping hashes safe.

# 9:57 pm / projects, sqlite, plugins, djp, datasette, django

Llama 3.2. In further evidence that AI labs are terrible at naming things, Llama 3.2 is a huge upgrade to the Llama 3 series - they've released their first multi-modal vision models!

Today, we’re releasing Llama 3.2, which includes small and medium-sized vision LLMs (11B and 90B), and lightweight, text-only models (1B and 3B) that fit onto edge and mobile devices, including pre-trained and instruction-tuned versions.

The 1B and 3B text-only models are exciting too, with a 128,000 token context length and optimized for edge devices (Qualcomm and MediaTek hardware get called out specifically).

Meta partnered directly with Ollama to help with distribution, here's the Ollama blog post. They only support the two smaller text-only models at the moment - this command will get the 3B model (2GB):

ollama run llama3.2

And for the 1B model (a 1.3GB download):

ollama run llama3.2:1b

I had to first upgrade my Ollama by clicking on the icon in my macOS task tray and selecting "Restart to update".

The two vision models are coming to Ollama "very soon".

Once you have fetched the Ollama model you can access it from my LLM command-line tool like this:

pipx install llm
llm install llm-ollama
llm chat -m llama3.2:1b

I tried running my djp codebase through that tiny 1B model just now and got a surprisingly good result - by no means comprehensive, but way better than I would ever expect from a model of that size:

files-to-prompt **/*.py -c | llm -m llama3.2:1b --system 'describe this code'

Here's a portion of the output:

The first section defines several test functions using the @djp.hookimpl decorator from the djp library. These hook implementations allow you to intercept and manipulate Django's behavior.

• test_middleware_order: This function checks that the middleware order is correct by comparing the MIDDLEWARE setting with a predefined list.
• test_middleware: This function tests various aspects of middleware:
• It retrieves the response from the URL /from-plugin/ using the Client object, which simulates a request to this view.
• It checks that certain values are present in the response:
  • X-DJP-Middleware-After
  • X-DJP-Middleware
  • X-DJP-Middleware-Before [...]

I found the GGUF file that had been downloaded by Ollama in my ~/.ollama/models/blobs directory. The following command let me run that model directly in LLM using the llm-gguf plugin:

llm install llm-gguf
llm gguf register-model ~/.ollama/models/blobs/sha256-74701a8c35f6c8d9a4b91f3f3497643001d63e0c7a84e085bed452548fa88d45 -a llama321b
llm chat -m llama321b

Meta themselves claim impressive performance against other existing models:

Our evaluation suggests that the Llama 3.2 vision models are competitive with leading foundation models, Claude 3 Haiku and GPT4o-mini on image recognition and a range of visual understanding tasks. The 3B model outperforms the Gemma 2 2.6B and Phi 3.5-mini models on tasks such as following instructions, summarization, prompt rewriting, and tool-use, while the 1B is competitive with Gemma.

Here's the Llama 3.2 collection on Hugging Face. You need to accept the new Llama 3.2 Community License Agreement there in order to download those models.

You can try the four new models out via the Chatbot Arena - navigate to "Direct Chat" there and select them from the dropdown menu. You can upload images directly to the chat there to try out the vision features.

# 8:28 pm / meta, vision-llms, generative-ai, llama, ai, llms

Solving a bug with o1-preview, files-to-prompt and LLM. I added a new feature to DJP this morning: you can now have plugins specify their middleware in terms of how it should be positioned relative to other middleware - inserted directly before or directly after django.middleware.common.CommonMiddleware for example.

At one point I got stuck with a weird test failure, and after ten minutes of head scratching I decided to pipe the entire thing into OpenAI's o1-preview to see if it could spot the problem. I used files-to-prompt to gather the code and LLM to run the prompt:

files-to-prompt **/*.py -c | llm -m o1-preview "
The middleware test is failing showing all of these - why is MiddlewareAfter repeated so many times?

['MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware3', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware5', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware3', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware2', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware3', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware5', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware3', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware4', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware3', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware5', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware3', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware2', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware3', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware5', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware3', 'MiddlewareAfter', 'Middleware', 'MiddlewareBefore']"

The model whirled away for a few seconds and spat out an explanation of the problem - one of my middleware classes was accidentally calling self.get_response(request) in two different places.

I did enjoy how o1 attempted to reference the relevant Django documentation and then half-repeated, half-hallucinated a quote from it:

This took 2,538 input tokens and 4,354 output tokens - by my calculations at $15/million input and $60/million output that prompt cost just under 30 cents.

# 6:41 pm / o1, llm, djp, openai, ai, llms, ai-assisted-programming, generative-ai

The Pragmatic Engineer Podcast: AI tools for software engineers, but without the hype – with Simon Willison. Gergely Orosz has a brand new podcast, and I was the guest for the first episode. We covered a bunch of ground, but my favorite topic was an exploration of the (very legitimate) reasons that many engineers are resistant to taking advantage of AI-assisted programming tools.

# 5:58 pm / podcasts, ai-assisted-programming, generative-ai, gergely-orosz, ai, llms

Updated production-ready Gemini models. Two new models from Google Gemini today: gemini-1.5-pro-002 and gemini-1.5-flash-002. Their -latest aliases will update to these new models in "the next few days", and new -001 suffixes can be used to stick with the older models. The new models benchmark slightly better in various ways and should respond faster.

Flash continues to have a 1,048,576 input token and 8,192 output token limit. Pro is 2,097,152 input tokens.

Google also announced a significant price reduction for Pro, effective on the 1st of October. Inputs less than 128,000 tokens drop from $3.50/million to $1.25/million (above 128,000 tokens it's dropping from $7 to $5) and output costs drop from $10.50/million to $2.50/million ($21 down to $10 for the >128,000 case).

For comparison, GPT-4o is currently $5/m input and $15/m output and Claude 3.5 Sonnet is $3/m input and $15/m output. Gemini 1.5 Pro was already the cheapest of the frontier models and now it's even cheaper.

Correction: I missed gpt-4o-2024-08-06 which is listed later on the OpenAI pricing page and priced at $2.50/m input and $10/m output. So the new Gemini 1.5 Pro prices are undercutting that.

Gemini has always offered finely grained safety filters - it sounds like those are now turned down to minimum by default, which is a welcome change:

For the models released today, the filters will not be applied by default so that developers can determine the configuration best suited for their use case.

Also interesting: they've tweaked the expected length of default responses:

For use cases like summarization, question answering, and extraction, the default output length of the updated models is ~5-20% shorter than previous models.

# 4:55 pm / gemini, google, generative-ai, ai, llms

nanodjango. Richard Terry demonstrated this in a lightning talk at DjangoCon US today. It's the latest in a long line of attempts to get Django to work with a single file (I had a go at this problem 15 years ago with djng) but this one is really compelling.

I tried nanodjango out just now and it works exactly as advertised. First install it like this:

pip install nanodjango

Create a counter.py file:

from django.db import models
from nanodjango import Django

app = Django()

@app.admin # Registers with the Django admin
class CountLog(models.Model):
    timestamp = models.DateTimeField(auto_now_add=True)

@app.route("/")
def count(request):
    CountLog.objects.create()
    return f"<p>Number of page loads: {CountLog.objects.count()}</p>"

Then run it like this (it will run migrations and create a superuser as part of that first run):

nanodjango run counter.py

That's it! This gave me a fully configured Django application with models, migrations, the Django Admin configured and a bunch of other goodies such as Django Ninja for API endpoints.

Here's the full documentation.

# 4:08 pm / radiac, django, python

XKCD 1425 (Tasks) turns ten years old today (via) One of the all-time great XKCDs. It's amazing that "check whether the photo is of a bird" has gone from PhD-level to trivially easy to solve (with a vision LLM, or CLIP, or ResNet+ImageNet among others).

The key idea still very much stands though. Understanding the difference between easy and hard challenges in software development continues to require an enormous depth of experience.

I'd argue that LLMs have made this even worse.

Understanding what kind of tasks LLMs can and cannot reliably solve remains incredibly difficult and unintuitive. They're computer systems that are terrible at maths and that can't reliably lookup facts!

On top of that, the rise of AI-assisted programming tools means more people than ever are beginning to create their own custom software.

These brand new AI-assisted proto-programmers are having a crash course in this easy-v.s.-hard problem.

I saw someone recently complaining that they couldn't build a Claude Artifact that could analyze images, even though they knew Claude itself could do that. Understanding why that's not possible involves understanding how the CSP headers that are used to serve Artifacts prevent the generated code from making its own API calls out to an LLM!

# 3:08 pm / clip, ai-assisted-programming, xkcd, ai, llms

Things I’ve Learned Serving on the Board of The Perl Foundation (via) My post about the PSF board inspired Perl Foundation secretary Makoto Nozaki to publish similar notes about how TPF (also known since 2019 as TPRF, for The Perl and Raku Foundation) operates.

Seeing this level of explanation about other open source foundations is fascinating. I’d love to see more of these.

Along those lines, I found the 2024 Financial Report from the Zig foundation really interesting too.

# 1:42 am / open-source, zig, perl, psf

simonw/docs cookiecutter template. Over the last few years I’ve settled on the combination of Sphinx, the Furo theme and the myst-parser extension (enabling Markdown in place of reStructuredText) as my documentation toolkit of choice, maintained in GitHub and hosted using ReadTheDocs.

My LLM and shot-scraper projects are two examples of that stack in action.

Today I wanted to spin up a new documentation site so I finally took the time to construct a cookiecutter template for my preferred configuration. You can use it like this:

pipx install cookiecutter
cookiecutter gh:simonw/docs

Or with uv:

uv tool run cookiecutter gh:simonw/docs

Answer a few questions:

[1/3] project (): shot-scraper
[2/3] author (): Simon Willison
[3/3] docs_directory (docs):

And it creates a docs/ directory ready for you to start editing docs:

cd docs
pip install -r requirements.txt
make livehtml

# 9:45 pm / uv, markdown, sphinx-docs, cookiecutter, read-the-docs, python, projects, documentation

Jiter (via) One of the challenges in dealing with LLM streaming APIs is the need to parse partial JSON - until the stream has ended you won't have a complete valid JSON object, but you may want to display components of that JSON as they become available.

I've solved this previously using the ijson streaming JSON library, see my previous TIL.

Today I found out about Jiter, a new option from the team behind Pydantic. It's written in Rust and extracted from pydantic-core, so the Python wrapper for it can be installed using:

pip install jiter

You can feed it an incomplete JSON bytes object and use partial_mode="on" to parse the valid subset:

import jiter
partial_json = b'{"name": "John", "age": 30, "city": "New Yor'
jiter.from_json(partial_json, partial_mode="on")
# {'name': 'John', 'age': 30}

Or use partial_mode="trailing-strings" to include incomplete string fields too:

jiter.from_json(partial_json, partial_mode="trailing-strings")
# {'name': 'John', 'age': 30, 'city': 'New Yor'}

The current README was a little thin, so I submiitted a PR with some extra examples. I got some help from files-to-prompt and Claude 3.5 Sonnet):

cd crates/jiter-python/ && files-to-prompt -c README.md tests | llm -m claude-3.5-sonnet --system 'write a new README with comprehensive documentation'

# 8:03 pm / json, python, ai-assisted-programming

How streaming LLM APIs work. New TIL. I used curl to explore the streaming APIs provided by OpenAI, Anthropic and Google Gemini and wrote up detailed notes on what I learned.

Also includes example code for receiving streaming events in Python with HTTPX and receiving streaming events in client-side JavaScript using fetch().

# 3:48 am / apis, http, llms, json

Markdown and Math Live Renderer. Another of my tiny Claude-assisted JavaScript tools. This one lets you enter Markdown with embedded mathematical expressions (like $ax^2 + bx + c = 0$) and live renders those on the page, with an HTML version using MathML that you can export through copy and paste.

Here's the Claude transcript. I started by asking:

Are there any client side JavaScript markdown libraries that can also handle inline math and render it?

Claude gave me several options including the combination of Marked and KaTeX, so I followed up by asking:

Build an artifact that demonstrates Marked plus KaTeX - it should include a text area I can enter markdown in (repopulated with a good example) and live update the rendered version below. No react.

Which gave me this artifact, instantly demonstrating that what I wanted to do was possible.

I iterated on it a tiny bit to get to the final version, mainly to add that HTML export and a Copy button. The final source code is here.

# 4:56 am / claude-3-5-sonnet, anthropic, claude, markdown, mathml, ai, llms, ai-assisted-programming, tools, generative-ai, claude-artifacts