LLM Flowbreaking (via) Gadi Evron from Knostic:
We propose that LLM Flowbreaking, following jailbreaking and prompt injection, joins as the third on the growing list of LLM attack types. Flowbreaking is less about whether prompt or response guardrails can be bypassed, and more about whether user inputs and generated model outputs can adversely affect these other components in the broader implemented system.
The key idea here is that some systems built on top of LLMs - such as Microsoft Copilot - implement an additional layer of safety checks which can sometimes cause the system to retract an already displayed answer.
I've seen this myself a few times, most notable with Claude 2 last year when it deleted an almost complete podcast transcript cleanup right in front of my eye because the hosts started talking about bomb threats.
Knostic calls this Second Thoughts, where an LLM system decides to retract its previous output. It's not hard for an attacker to grab this potentially harmful data: I've grabbed some using a quick copy and paste, or you can use tricks like video scraping or using the network browser tools.
They also describe a Stop and Roll attack, where the user clicks the "stop" button while executing a query against a model in a way that also prevents the moderation layer from having the chance to retract its previous output.
I'm not sure I'd categorize this as a completely new vulnerability class. If you implement a system where output is displayed to users you should expect that attempts to retract that data can be subverted - screen capture software is widely available these days.
I wonder how widespread this retraction UI pattern is? I've seen it in Claude and evidently ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot have the same feature. I don't find it particularly convincing - it seems to me that it's more safety theatre than a serious mechanism for avoiding harm caused by unsafe output.
Recent articles
- First impressions of the new Amazon Nova LLMs (via a new llm-bedrock plugin) - 4th December 2024
- Storing times for human events - 27th November 2024
- Ask questions of SQLite databases and CSV/JSON files in your terminal - 25th November 2024