Feed Sign in with OpenID OpenID

Simon Willison’s Weblog

Facebook's new signup process. It looks like they’ve dropped the “enter your password twice” pattern. Is this really a good idea? I suppose if people mis-type it they can always use forgotten password to set a new one.

Tagged , ,

5 comments

  1. If we never challenged an existing decision, nothing would ever change.

    I think so long interface appropriately highlights the 'forgot your password' link - I doubt it'd have much impact.

    If you felt squeamish about the change though - you could collect some simple statistics to find out how many times incorrect password/.. events happen and base it on that.

    Al - 12th December 2008 14:17 - #

  2. It suddenly seems utterly obvious in retrospect to look at server logs and find out what proportion of people don't type the same password twice..

    Tom Insam - 12th December 2008 14:17 - #

  3. It'd be nice if password inputs had a "Show password" option like the AirPort WEP/WPA dialog. 99% of the time, the only person my password gets hidden from is myself.

    phl - 12th December 2008 16:07 - #

  4. ...assuming they entered their email address correctly.

    (My keyboard occasionally drops 'z', so I have to be careful on sites that don't ask twice.)

    John Morton - 12th December 2008 18:22 - #

  5. Actually I've seen a lot of my friends just copy-paste the password into the "confirm password" box. And that pretty much defeats the purpose of this mechanism anyways.

    Harish Mallipeddi - 13th December 2008 09:20 - #

Comments are closed.
A django site